The Sinfulness of Sin


“So Pilate said to [Jesus], “You will not speak to me? Do you not know that I have authority to release you and authority to crucify you?” Jesus answered him, “You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above. Therefore he who delivered me over to you has the greater sin.” (John 19:10–11)
Each Sunday, as part of our corporate worship, we recite and reflect on Spurgeon's Catechism.
This past weekend question and answer raised a few eyebrows.
The question was: "Is all breaking of the law equally wicked?"
The answer? "Some sins in their very nature and effect, are worse than others in God’s eyes."
WHOA…. Wait. A. Minute!! Back your Baptist bus back up!
Have we not been told for years that “All sin is the same in God’s eyes?” I mean, “sin is sin, isn’t it?” So, which is it?!?
Well (as has happened on occasion), I was later asked for an explanation.
I love it when church members are tuned in and thinking deeply about theological issues. I love it even more when they pursue answers – instead of dismissing curiosity, grumbling against disagreement, or (even worse) spreading gossip and misinformation because something didn’t “sit right” with them.
While I was able to provide adequate, “on the spot” answers, I was personally unsatisfied with my explanations, so I did some research and found some articles on Monday in hope of developing some more precise and better-framed answers.
First, we can start with a general definition of “sin.”
The Bible employs a handful of expressions to communicate sin. One of the more popular word pictures for sin is an archer who misses the target. The primary Greek word for “sin” is hamartia (ἁμαρτία); it literally means "to miss the mark." Our decisions, thinking, and intentions all “fall short” of God’s holy design (Rom 3:23). We cannot achieve the righteousness that God requires. Our lives, like the errant arrow, may miss by a little bit or miss by a great deal—but the result is the same: The arrow doesn’t land where it is supposed to.
Now, here is where the “all sin is sin” sentiment rings true. We all sin, and all sin is from the common sinful root of rebellion against God. We all flex our autonomy from our Creator, and therefore, we all stand under the appropriate wrath of a holy God.
Also, all sin can be forgiven if we will acknowledge our guilt and repent. The same sacrifice that covers lying, washes away adultery; the same blood that cleanses the gossip atones for the murderer.
In this respect, all sin separates us from God, and the only remedy for any and all sin is the sacrificial death of Jesus on the cross.
We never want to assume the position of arbiter, determining which sins are more grievous than others. Such a practice reeks of self-righteousness and is unavoidably self-deceptive. The sin that should bother us the most should always be our own; we are not ever in a position to compare our sins against anyone else’s.
So, in one sense, it is true that “all sins are the same.”
However, in another sense, there is an intuitive uneasiness with the claim that all sins are the same. Indeed, the statement can invite accusations against God’s justice. It seems unjust to put liars and rapists in the same category, and to equate cowards with serial killers. We have a very real sense that there is a clear distinction among sins. Sins vary in motivation, degrees of depravity, and severity of consequence, and consequently (we reason) they should be judged accordingly. Stealing food to feed your family is vastly different than killing someone over a parking space.
The Mosaic law required different penalties for different offenses and called for different sacrifices and payments to make restitution. The Mosaic law also distinguished between “unintentional” sins and “high-handed” sins (Num. 15:29-30). Sins of deliberate idolatry and persistent rebellion received more serious indictments on the kings of Israel and Judah than the sin of failing to remove the “high places” in the land.
Not only do we see in Scripture that various sins receive different levels of rebuke, we also observe that different people received different degrees of judgment. God’s anger burned strongest against the leaders of His people. Meaning, the sin of a king or the priests or the elders was met with (and will be met with) greater judgment than the sins of the people.
So, what we have observed so far: (1) the gravity of a wrong, (2) the motivation of the heart, and (3) the position/responsibility of the offender, these things determine the degree of punishment and severity of rebuke for particular sins. We also see a fourth factor that shapes God’s words against and response to a sin: (4) the victim of the offense. God’s anger appears especially aroused when sins are against children, the weak, or the helpless (Jer. 32:35; Matt. 18:6; Luke 20:47).
In Jesus’ teaching and ministry, He indicates degrees of judgment and consequence. When speaking of the final judgment, Jesus announces that it would be bearable for Sodom and Gomorrah than for the towns that personally witnessed His miracles and teaching for they personally and directly rejected their Messiah. Here again, who we sin against shapes the seriousness of our sin. Sins against Christ, blasphemies against the Holy Spirit, these receive ultimate condemnation because God is the ultimate good and the highest authority.
We cannot insist that every sin is the same in God’s eyes. I understand why we say it: we don’t want to arrogantly and self-righteously compare sin, and we never want to communicate that any sin is beyond the forgiving and restoring power of God’s grace. We must diligently avoid both of those gospel-denying errors.
However, there are also potentially negative repercussions to the “all sin is equal” position. The seriousness of sin can be diminished. “Sin is sin” can cultivate a flippant attitude toward sin and undercut serious thought concerning sin. It can even discourage proper repentance over sin… after all, “nobody’s perfect.” We never want to take sin lightly, for it was our sin that put Jesus on the cross and cost Him His life. Equating all sin can lead to disproportionate shame over common sins or even insulating our hearts from the inherent warnings from recognizing the gravity of more serious sins.
We never want to self-righteously compare sins; all sin separates us from God, and every sin can be forgiven, washed under the blood of Jesus. At the same time, we also want to see sin as God does, recognizing the greater responsibility placed on leaders, the protection due to the vulnerable, and the warning signs that flash when sin increases in our own lives, not to mention the greater risk we encounter as sin expands in our hearts.
Ultimately we know that all sin is against God; no sin can ever be inconsequential because any rebellion against Him deserves the full consequences for betraying our most noble and innocent Savior.
In the gospel, we can learn to see sin clearly, confess sin deeply, and then walk away from sin freely, knowing and sharing the joy that comes from living in the shadow and power of the cross.



Comments